BigRedEO
Service Attendant
Well, I stopped reading every post in this thread when it become an argument rather than a discussion, but to throw in my two cents, I've taken the Pennsylvanian three times in the past year round-trip, PGH-NYP and back (I'm in the Cleveland area). I would rather drive the 2 hours to PGH than risk the Cap Ltd running late, which has been EVERY TIME I have taken a train out of Cleveland or PGH. I used to take the Pennsy from Cleveland to Chicago - many times - when it used to leave at 6pm from Cleveland. That was PERFECT for leaving directly out of work downtown to the station. LOVED it! So it makes me very happy that they might bring it back - would love to be able to head east or west out of Cleveland at more reasonable hours. But if there is 2 to 4 hours waiting in PGH, then it would defeat the purpose and I might as well just make the 2 hour drive to and from PGH again anyway.