Great Middle Western Odyssey '09

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
pictures one of these days, really, but in the meantime, here's the story of our trip home:

BTL>CHI

To save the in-laws a drive to Chicago, we arranged to ride the Wolverine from Battle Creek to Chicago, where we’d catch the Capitol Limited back East. The train was listed as on time when we left the house, but had slipped back 10 minutes or so by the time we reached the station, where we were glad of the opportunity to wait in their van rather than the crowded station with its bizarre pressed steel decor.

When the train arrived it was fairly crowded, but after walking through a few cars we found two seats together, albeit in a car where every seat faced backwards. This train had a regular, new engine at both ends, unlike the Blue Water we took to Battle Creek, which had an engine in front and a cabbage in the rear. Perhaps it gets pushed back to Chicago? (Cabbages don’t have engines anymore, right?)

The train stayed 15 minutes or so down for the entire ride, which was otherwise uneventful. Snow lay deep everywhere we went, and at times it was also falling heavily. We nonetheless pulled into Chicago close to on time.
 
Second Chicago Interlude:

We checked into the Metropolitan Lounge at about 4:30 and made a dinner reservation for 7:30, reasoning that we were hungry enough to need a snack before the train boarded at 5:45 and that the snack would hold us for a few hours. With our bags stored in the lounge, we bundled up and headed out of the station.

The weather did a good job of reminding us Chitown ex-pats why we’d left. Snowing and cold, of course — the truly knowledgeable will note that snow is good news for Chicago temperatures in January, since that means it’s not TOO COLD TO SNOW, an idea to strike fear in my Carolina heart — and with every street corner blocked by immense lakes of dirty slush puddles, requiring leaps from the curb into traffic in order to cross the street without galoshes. I am pleased to report that I did not fall, despite several close calls, nor were we sliced open by the falling ice that signs in front of every skyscraper warned us to beware of. (What a person is supposed to do once wary I’ve never understood, unless it’s stay home until late spring.)

After a quick side trip to CVS for toothpaste, we decided to try Boston Blackie’s, where a man stood right at the window slicing roast beef and ham onto plates held by the kind of Chicago stockbroker who looks, as I believe Mark Twain once remarked of Chicago men in general, like he could personally butcher a steer. Now, I know you on this board are die-hard Giordanos/Gold Coast Dogs fans, but I do recommend Blackie’s to you. The service couldn’t be better, the situation more comfortable, and for $4.99, they will bring you something called “Frings”: a half-POUND of onion straws in a metal basket, surrounded on all sides by heaps of home-style potato fries. I promised myself when we ordered that I would eat only enough for a snack, regardless of how much was put before me, but I regret to say that in this matter I let myself down. (Okay, I don’t regret it at all. I regret only that my anticipation of a steak dinner kept me from joining the line at the carving station)

Upon our return to the Metropolitan Lounge — after another visit to CVS for prophylactic Pepcid — we requested that our dinner reservation be moved as late as possible and sat down to rub our bellies and smile until the train boarded.
 
CUS>WAS on the Cap:

Boarded early from Lounge — wish we’d waited, as we didn’t want to eat early enough to justify sitting around on the train for so long in the station, but we also didn’t want to miss the train. Unfortunately, we’re in roommette #11, so right by the door and the stairs again.

Somewhere near Gary, we stop for freight traffic for…so far maybe an hour or so? Supposedly the freights are having switching problems. There is something Chris Van Allsburg-y about the industrial landscape here, so after a little griping, I got out my sketchbook and did a rather ham-fisted drawing of the scene, which did pass the time. I think this might have to become my new habit for times when the train stops, as it makes a virtue of necessity. The train is going so slowly now that I could almost draw the rest of this — I believe we were just out-paced by a snowflake. If only I had fast enough film to capture the surreal video billboard of the casino we just passed, where pennies fly through the air, salad bars slide past plates of sliced steak, and women walk from office cubicles to Caribbean beaches, all on a glowing square aloft in the snowy sky.

Around 10 o’clock Eastern, we began to worry that we had missed hearing our 8:30 dinner reservation called. (This isn’t as crazy as it sounds. Dinner reservations were keeping Central time, so it was 9:00 according to the diner, and everything seemed to get delayed while we sat still.) We headed up to the diner to see and were sent back by a harried-looking crew member, who told us they would call when they were ready. When we apologized and said we’d only worried we hadn’t heard the call, she suddenly turned sweet, assuring us that they would not let us miss dinner.

The call came soon enough, and we joined a young couple who were taking a sleeper from Chicago to Pittsburgh because it sounded romantic. They were in a good mood, and by the time the attendant — Beverly — reached our table, so was she, clearly driven a bit punchy by difficult passengers at earlier seatings (including at least one set who wandered back to their sleeper without paying for their bottle of wine, and perhaps also including the good natured but rather tipsy women at a nearby table, who carried on about why anybody would ever live in Ohio and how they’d ever stood to live there so long. They later attempted to go down the kitchen stairs instead of to their car.) We had a marvelous time with her. She alternately praised three of us for being good, easy passengers and ragged on the fourth, scolding him for having filled out his order ticket before we could stop him. “Premium Ice Cream! He wants premium — do you even know what premium ice cream is? You tell me, what is premium ice cream?” He played along very nicely, and we all had a good time. (And he was glad he didn’t get premium ice cream, since that turns out to mean Ciao Bella Lemon Sorbet.)

What we did not have, I regret to inform, was a good dinner. Three of us ordered steak, and was I ever red-faced for having recommended it! I am certain they never saw a grill — in fact, I’m pretty sure they were microwaved. None was medium-rare as ordered; mine was well-done. Ugh. Mind you, these were meant to be steaks, not the braised beef I’ve ordered in the past. I suppose we should have sent them back, but I had no belief that something better would have followed. (And I couldn’t claim great hunger, given the pounds of fried potato I’d eaten in Chicago….) The succotash was surprisingly good, and the baked potato was as usual — a bit overcooked but basically good. Despite the menu’s promises of wine by the glass, only half-bottles were available, so we skipped that (since we prefer different kinds). We all four had ice cream — regular ice cream — for dessert, which was pleasant as usual. But oh, that steak! Rare are the occasions on which I send much meat back on my plate, let alone steak. In fact, I can’t think of another time it’s happened in my life, certainly not on our CL journey west, only a couple weeks back. A grave disappointment.

Our beds were turned back when we returned for dinner (making me feel a bit guilty for not straightening up the room before we left*), and we turned in soon after. Worn out by in-laws and travel, I slept very well, waking only briefly in Pittsburgh to watch the Carnegie Mellon cupola glide by overhead.

One thing I like very much about the brunch schedule on the CL is the freedom it affords to sleep late without missing breakfast. We stayed in bed hours later than usual, finally dressing and coming upstairs just before 11:00. We were in Cumberland then, still about an hour down. Beverly brought us breakfast — including iced tea for me ☺ — and let us sit over it, reading the paper and enjoying the view, long after the diner had stopped serving. Again, while the service in the diner was great, the food was unimpressive. My grits and sausage (I never really eat the eggs) were okay, though I think the sausage was microwaved, but my wife’s french toast was horribly tough.

It was a perfect day to ride along the Potomac. There was heavy snow and ice all the way to Rockville, and early clouds gave way to stunning blue sky. We saw many geese, crows and turkey vultures and also a black vulture and two glorious Bald Eagles, wheeling over the river. For a while, we sat in the SSL to get a little more light, but we were back in our room when the conductor came on the intercom to announce that we would be stopping outside of Germantown, MD, because, “our friends at CSX are having trouble with a broken road block.” Crew from our train had, by regulation, to get out and stand in the road to be sure it was clear for the train to pass, which took some time and made us even later coming into WAS. When we pulled in to WAS about an hour and a half late, the conductor mentioned in his announcement (and lateness apology) that we were at the mercy of freight dispatchers, making clear which lines we were on at each point in the trip. His tone was not overly harsh, but I think it’s wise to let riders know that lateness often isn’t Amtrak’s fault (and perhaps what names they should mention in any aggrieved letters to congressmen). Finally, he reminded us, “Elvis has left the building.”

*Post-Script: The attendant (Darryl) also made our beds into chairs while we were eating breakfast, again having left the room disorderly. I didn’t think much of it at the time — it was a bit weird to have it done without his asking us, but it was getting late, so his assumption didn’t seem unreasonable — but now I REALLY wish he’d waited. Upon our return to New York, we discovered that he must have tossed half of a brand-new (Christmas gift) set of pajamas onto the top bunk with the sheets. Since it wasn’t visible when we were packing up later, we didn’t notice its absence until we were headed to bed at home, by which point (according to the Lost and Found man at WAS, whom I called the next morning) it was long ago thrown away by a car cleaner.

I know we should have been neater and more careful, but it’s still a disappointment to lose something in this manner. Great thanks to Garnet Hill, the company that sold the pajamas, though. When I called to see if by any chance they could sell me just a top — factory second, whatever — they kindly offered a complete set at less than half the usual price.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Washington Interlude

Despite our late arrival, we still had plenty of time before our Regional to New York at 4:25, so we decided to see if we could switch to the 3:25 and get home a bit earlier. We headed to the ticket counter, but found that it would be $100 to switch trains. I’m a little confused about how Regional pricing works when connecting to Long-DIstance trains, but it seems crazy to me that we couldn’t just switch, assuming the train wasn’t sold out. It was a Saturday, and the station was very quiet. (I suppose we could have just risked boarding with the wrong tickets, but that is more stress than I care for without a good reason.)

Since we couldn’t get home sooner, we stuck to our original plan of having lunch at Union Station. We ate this year at “America,” one of the corner cafes in the main hall. It was a nice place, and I’d recommend it over Thunder Grill, where we ate last year. The menu was varied, the service lovely, and the murals on the walls fun to look at. I don’t particularly recommend the pulled pork sandwich, but I am a tremendous barbeque snob and knew from the outset that it wasn’t a wise choice for me. The cole slaw was very good, though, and my wife liked her steak sandwich.

After lunch we spent a few minutes in the Club Acela before leaving to board train 146 home.
 
WAS>NYP

There wasn’t much of a crowd waiting for 146, by the standards of WAS, and we had no trouble finding space for our suitcases and seats together. (We decided not to check our bags through on the LSL, since it only gets into NYP an hour before we would and we hated the idea of sitting around Penn if it ran late.) So far the train is running quickly — deliciously quickly, after the trains we’ve been on in the past day — and has hit every station right on time. The sunset was brilliant red as we crossed over an icy arm of the Chesapeake north of Baltimore.

…The train remained on time all the way to NYP. Sadly, the subways were a complete disaster, and it took us double the usual time to get home. The first line we tried turned out to be replaced by a bus for our destination (no good with luggage); the second two weren’t even running to Brooklyn or a reasonable transfer point (only point available was an outdoor transfer, again awful with luggage); ended up going uptown to Times Square and catching the Q to Brooklyn. The fact that so many options are even possibilities for us is all thanks to the best little train in NYC:

4220071422_19376f39bd.jpg
 
Thanks for an excellent report! AND for shedding some light on the Franklin Avenue Shuttle, which never gets much attention.

One of the things I miss about living in New York is that even if one subway line is down, you can get to quite a few neighborhoods by taking another line around it. When I lived in Forest Hills, I had my choice of the E, or the 7 to the E, or the N to the 7 to the E... or the F... or (rarely) the G... or heaven forbid the pokey V!
 
The Franklin Ave shuttle doesn't get a lot of attention for two reasons, one it doesn't really go anywhere. Two, it was the scene of the worst accident in NYC subway history, the Malbone Street wreck that killed some 97 people in 1918. So they try to keep it out of the limelight as it were.

They even changed the name of the street after that wreck because of that, it's now called Empire Blvd. Additionally the tunnel where the wreck happened now goes unused by the S shuttle, this is why they always come in on the inbound platform for the B & Q trains at Prospect Park.
 
The Franklin Ave shuttle doesn't get a lot of attention for two reasons, one it doesn't really go anywhere.
I beg your pardon -- it goes right to my house! ;)

My understanding is that the Franklin shuttle is some of the oldest "subway" track in NYC, as it was originally part of the line that extends to Coney Island.

It's most used by people traveling within Brooklyn -- you should see the swarms of teenagers coming to and from school -- so naturally it's not of much interest to those outside the borough. I adore it, though: it runs very regularly, it connects my un-fancy address to 7 different lines (C, 2/3, 4/5, B, Q), and it's the most likely train in the system to hold the doors as you run across the platform. There are so few drivers that most of us know them all by sight and temperament. My only complaint about it is the late night schedule -- during regular hours, the line has two trains, one going each direction. (Two cars each -- adorable.) Because there's only one spot where they can pass each other (Botanic Garden; the rest of the line is only one track), one pauses for a long time at one end of the line (Prospect Park) so that the other train can catch up, which all makes sense. Late nights, though, there's only one train running, so it's irritating that it waits just as long (needlessly), making your wait time on a given platform double.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My understanding is that the Franklin shuttle is some of the oldest "subway" track in NYC, as it was originally part of the line that extends to Coney Island.
It is indeed some of the oldest track around. The line connects on the southern end with the Brighton Line (the current B & Q line) and runs to CI. The current connection that the B & Q use to reach Manhattan did not exist and the trains continued up to Franklin Avenue. For a number of years, before electrification, the line terminated there. As electrification spread and the Fulton Street El was built to carry what in effect is today's A train, this line was connected to the Fulton El in 1896 and trains were able to run from CI to Manhattan.

Come the 1920's when the current connection used by the B & Q was built, the connection to the Fulton El was severed and the Shuttle was born. The last train to ever run on the Fulton Street El did so on May 31st 1940, replaced by the current underground expressway of the IND.

Because there's only one spot where they can pass each other (Botanic Garden; the rest of the line is only one track), one pauses for a long time at one end of the line (Prospect Park) so that the other train can catch up, which all makes sense.
At one time it was fully a two track line, but the current shuttle simply doesn't need all that extra track and associated costs that come with it. Not sure why they sit so long, other than perhaps to give the operator time to change ends and perhaps pay a visit to the facilities.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top