Wow, I just looked at the timetable and Amtrak really needs to rethink this connection. They should not be offering a connection in NY at all. They should only connect 195 to 91 in DC.
I suspect that the reason they are still offering this connection, is due to a screw up in the TT. If you look at the corridor part of the TT, it shows 195 arriving in NYP at 10:50 AM. With the departure of the Star at 11:30, that is far less than the 1 hour minimum.
However, the reason that they are still offering this connection is because, when you flip to the Florida/Carolinian page of the TT you find 95/195 listed as arriving at 10:20, which is within the 1 hour minimum. Apparently when they rearranged 195's schedule to be half an hour later than 95, no one ever pulled that connection.