Recent content by Anderson

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. A

    Proposal for moving VIA Rail out of Saskatoon to Warman

    So, if VIA is going to do this, they really need some sort of bus/taxi connection into town. Admittedly there are only about 20 pax/train per those numbers (2x/week in each direction equals 208 departures per year), but that just tells me that they could cover demand for that with a large van...
  2. A

    Acela discussion

    It's a good question whether that's an Amtrak-induced thing or if MNRR insists on it.
  3. A

    Acela discussion

    At the time, DCA-LGA on AA (IIRC) still ran close to hourly. I recall it being a big deal when they cut one midday frequency. [I'm also not sure if that 75% included onward connections on either side, but connecting traffic only needs 3-5x/day, not hourly service. It's where the market is...
  4. A

    Acela discussion

    From what I recall from plans 10-15 years ago, there *are* some cheaper time savings to be had (don't forget that the Acelas were running like 10 minutes faster back in '18 or '19, and I legitimately speculated that a nonstop time of 2:30 WAS-NYP was in sight w/improvements and new trains, and...
  5. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    Yeah. It seems to have been a random idea Tampa came up with. It isn't even clear what the money is /for/, either. Edit: It sorta calls into question FL getting picked for Corridor ID...but as you said, DeSantis is about to term out.
  6. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    So, I'm sticking by my phrasing, but only because I don't think it is unreasonable to wag a finger at them about impossible-to-meet-due-to-lack-of-equipment ridership projections. The issue is that, particularly once they get to some point, either they're not buying their projections or they're...
  7. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    I'd say half an hour of wait time per call.
  8. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    Mine are different insofar as they got "stuck" building a commuter market down there for a few years, building up a non-trivial passholder base. To be fair, I think they mismanaged the equipment order timing (as I've said repeatedly, even the close-in portions of their ridership projections...
  9. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    So, about 9 sets are needed. You absolutely need 8 for the current schedule (3:25-3:30 for travel plus an apparent 30-ish minute allowance for turning), but this promptly effectively goes to 9 if there are any slow orders whatsoever (I think they effectively needed 9 to run the full schedule...
  10. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    They're fine at four cars (now). I think the trolley might get a bit overwhelmed once you're around 7 cars (that might require a second attendant, and the cart only has but so much space). This feels like a case where a reasonable call could be made either way.
  11. A

    Can Private Railroads operate passenger service without government help?

    Or, in the case of Auto-Train, they pushed into an unwise expansion and then had those derailments. [I strongly suspect that if Auto-Train had stuck to LOR-SFA alone, they might still be operating.]
  12. A

    Pennsylvanian (the train(s) and route) discussion

    Eh, helping a friend/family member to the train strikes me as a valid reason to be on the platform. Not on the train, but at least the platform, especially if the red caps aren't being particularly useful.
  13. A

    Can Private Railroads operate passenger service without government help?

    I didn't realize it got there in 2017 (I recall it going into the black during a few summers, but not it getting all the way there). Having said that, IIRC the Alaska RR is in a similar boat (though winter demand there was also rising pre-pandemic - for a few years they were running winter...
  14. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    VA Regionals, at least, have often had 7-9 revenue cars over the years (8-10 car trains being reasonably common, aside from the reverse-peak ones, especially pre-pandemic). The cafe on the Carolinian gets more crowded, but that's probably a function of the train carrying more longer-distance...
  15. A

    Brightline Trains Florida discussion 2024 H1

    Yeah, that's a lot more workable. I don't see the cafes on the Regionals slam full that often (I don't know about the Acela, since I haven't been up there in like...10-15 years), so a half-cafe/half-coach would probably suffice.
Back
Top