So I finally did a roomette from Slidell to Atlanta,since Slidell is unmanned I had my luggage and a friend decided to come along and I must say to each his own. Maybe if I were by myself it would have been different,but I felt closed in and more crowded than when I did coach coming back. I have always done either done bedroom A,B or H. I don't think I could have done overnight in roomette. I used to complain about the bathroom in the bedroom,but the toilet in the roomette. Nah. I used points for this trip and that was a plus,also meals were great. The attendant was not seen until time to get off. We still gave him a small tip,but is that required if he is missing in action for the whole trip.I think I will try business class next. And then what do you do in coach when there is a bratty kid sitting behind you pulling your hair and all the mom is saying is "stop",Don't do that. They only went 3 stops with us and boy was I glad.